Trending Content

To TAD or Not to TAD… That is the Question

By MARK RUSHTON

March 31, 2026

Yes, it’s a bit of a play on a Shakspearian theme, but this issue’s Setpoint headline poses a serious question; To install Through Air Drying (TAD) technology, or stick to conventional tissue machines?

So, I have made it my mission since the last issue to dig deep into the TAD world and find out what top experts, producers, suppliers and consultants think about the advancement of TAD and its future.

My first port of call was to speak to paper and tissue veteran Bruce Janda about the history of TAD. I found out that the technology first hit the tissue production scene in the 1950s and early 1960s and was pioneered by two engineers at Procter & Gamble’s East River Mill in Green Bay, Wisconsin. These enthusiastic early innovators developed TAD on a small commercial tissue machine, often working weekends, and occasionally causing mill fires!

Other early innovators were Scott, Kimberly-Clark, and American Can, which used high-speed pilot plants first, while P&G pursued development directly on commercial equipment. American Can later evolved into James River/Fort James/Georgia-Pacific. Crown Zellerbach contributed a unique TAD system in the early 1980s, later integrated into James River and still in use.

HIGHLY EFFECTIVE FOR PREMIUM PRODUCTS—BUT A MAJOR ENERGY CHALLENGE

Fast forward to the 2020s and the technology has been proved over the decades to be highly effective at producing ultra-soft bathroom tissue and toweling. Globally, it is prized for being highly absorbent, using less fiber, offering superior bulk, softness, and absorbency over conventional wet-pressed methods. Consumers are basically delighted with what TAD can bring into their homes and businesses.

Although the technology has been widely adopted (TAD now accounts for over 30 percent of tissue production capacity in the US), there is one major challenge—TAD uses a lot of energy. The technology is well-known for higher energy consumption compared to conventional tissue drying methods (like dry crepe or wet pressing with Yankee dryers). This stems from the lack of mechanical pressing: TAD relies almost entirely on evaporating water using hot air forced through the sheet on perforated cylinders, rather than removing much water mechanically.

TAD typically requires about twice as much thermal energy to evaporate water per unit of fiber compared to conventional processes, because incoming sheets enter the dryer at lower dryness. As drying accounts for around 70 percent of total energy use in tissue production, this is a significant increase in demand.

This extra energy cost is obviously a deterrent to tissue producers operating in high energy cost regions like Europe. TAD technology is also avoided by sustainability aware companies due to extra fossil fuel use and a larger carbon footprint.

In this issue we have an excellent interview with Jérôme Porlier, head of tissue at Cascades, a company that is not going down the TAD route currently due to energy and sustainability concerns as well as its view that consumers are not perceiving enough added value in TAD bath tissue to justify the lower sheet count per roll and the higher price per pack. “What consumers really want is more sheets and better value,” Porlier says.

THE HOLY GRAIL:
A SOLUTION TO THE ENERGY PROBLEM

There is no doubt that TAD has revolutionized the quality of tissue across the industry and as Janda says, the technology is the No. 1 innovation the industry has seen in modern times. However, the energy problem has been a major stumbling block to outright adoption.

Fortunately, we have excellent and innovative suppliers to the tissue industry who are variously searching for the holy grail of solutions to the energy problem. We are already seeing some extraordinary results. Take a look at the article on converting company Gambini with its AirMill wet embossing technology which is, it says, “bringing a piece of the paper mill into converting” with its TAD-type technology.

Breaking news is that there is an exciting solution from a major supplier to the industry but alas, I am not allowed to talk about it yet! The new innovation, which will be launched at Tissue World in Miami in April, is set to drop energy demand in TAD production by 30 percent and beyond!

You can read more in this issue from Bruce Janda in our My Industry section on page 26 , along with features on Cascades, page 11 and Gambini page 15.

Happy reading!

Post Tags